Thursday, July 27, 2006

Tuning into Chennai Traffic

Three weeks ago I flew to Kuala Lampur to extend my Indian visa. I was staying with someone I met online and spent several days walking through the city, checking out upscale malls and marveling at the public transportation. Then, over a deeply fried fish in Chinatown, my host sipped a bit of herbal tea and proceeded to tell me why traffic in Kuala Lampur was so bad.

"There are just too many cars--and there are a lot of people who learned to drive in the village and didn't improve once they got to the city," he said.

I was shocked. Not only does Kuala Lampur have extremely well designed roads, but, for the most part, people obey traffic laws. No one runs red lights, there are very few potholes and police have cracked down on drunk driving. Occasionally, during rush hour, people have to sit in their cars for a while, but the jams begin to clear up quickly.

It is normal to complain about the traffic in your city as there is no place on earth where occasional road backups don't mangle your plans. Kuala Lampur is no exception. But when I began to tell my host the traffic situation here in Chennai, I think he came away with a
little better appreciation for his civic infrastructure.

As far as I can tell there are no laws--or at least no one seems to be familiar with them. Run red lights, travel on the wrong side of the road, run down a pedestrian, go slow in a passing lane, don't use a lane at all, cut someone off just to stop in front of them--if you are driving in India it really doesn't matter what you do to get to your final destination.

Every morning before I jump on my motorcycle I wonder if this might be the last time I ever drive. No one wears a helmet, and I see at least one crash a week. Not long ago I was in Pondicherry and I helped move two dying men from the road who had crashed into one another while angry onlookers honked their horns and wondered what was causing the delay. At least three motorcyclists barged their way through the standstill and came dangerously close to running over the prone bodies on their way past. When traffic did start to flow agai I was sure that there were at least a few dirty looks cast my way and I wiped blood from my hands and waited for an ambulance.

Sharing the road with everything from bicycles and rickshaws to motorcycles, buses, camels and cows innumerably extends the sorts of accidents that you can get caught up in. Every day the Deccan Chronicle gives short listings of fatal accidents that usually involve gruesome details of people run over by buses after falling from motorcycles, burned alive when they hit live wires, falling into unseen trenches, and decapitations from un-helmeted people slamming
into the backs of lories.

On the roads the only rule that has any meaning is "might makes right": the bigger you are the more freedom you have to do anything you want. I find it crazy that under Indian traffic law, if you cause a fatal accident, you can usually get off with a fine of only Rs 1500. I know at least one person, who completely at fault, killed someone and was free to continue driving as early as the next day.

I can think of at least a few solutions that might make the problem easier. First, the police need to be empowered to stop, ticket and tow any violators. While there are hundreds of police on the road directing traffic right now, none of them have radios, handcuffs, or even books of tickets to distribute. When a lawbreaker gets directed to the side of the road, more often then not they just speed past and the cop is powerless to do anything about it.

Second, the police need some sort of incentive to actually do their job. Since most traffic cops make something like rs 700 a month (!), it might be a good idea to give the officers rs 10 every time they stop and ticket someone. Not only would it drive up revenues for road improvements, but also the police would have strong motivation to start doing their job. After only a couple of months you would begin to see huge changes in the way that people approach driving.

9 Comments:

At July 28, 2006 10:08 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...


it might be a good idea to give the officers rs 10 every time they stop and ticket someone. Not only would it drive up revenues for road improvements, but also the police would have strong motivation to start doing their job. After only a couple of months you would begin to see huge changes in the way that people approach driving.


ehh, you think it's not been tried before? I won't accuse you of condenscenion here but the inability to see another viewpoint.

Have you seen how a driving license is acquired? Then you will understand. A combination of

a) no driving handbook
b) no testing of reading skills
c) a perfunctory ddriving test
d) c) done without you needed there( a surrogate does it for you)

and a bunch of other things. Enforcement cames AFTER you violate them KNOWINGLY. For most people, ignorance of the law leads to clashes with the police over the 'alleged' violation.

Then there's the small matter of the fence eating the crop of policemen demanding more bribes.

BTW, you'll notice the checking increases during the end of the month cash crunch of the patrol men.

shanks

 
At July 28, 2006 11:22 AM, Blogger Scott Carney said...

I wasn't aware that this had been tried before. Of course I am aware of all the backdoor licensing schemes, but I don't think that is an excuse to avoid enforcement of the laws. Indeed, ignorance of the law is not an excuse to break the law. And it isn't an argument that holds up in court.

Police corruption is another matter, too. I am sure that if the policy I suggested actually was implimented that it would sharply increase the number of bribes that police demand, but then again, if you consider the number of lives that it might save I think I would choose the lesser of two evils.

 
At July 29, 2006 9:40 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

When friends ask me how my trip to India was, I tell them that they haven't _LIVED_ until they attempt to cross the street...

 
At August 01, 2006 10:37 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I understand how you would feel about driving in India especially after driving in US or UK. When I was UK, I had seen couple of people making fun of driving in Italy but guess they had not seen the situation in India.

First of all, drivers in India does not have even little patience. They cannot wait few seconds to let pass the traffic for which there is right-of-way, they cannot wait two seconds till the traffic in front of them starts moving when light turn green, they cannot give even a foot gap with the vehicle in front of them or they cannot drive two seconds more to take a u-turn up in road to avoid a driving in one-way. People are people everywhere. Guess what would happen if no-cops on the patrol in US or any other country? Definitely people would run over lights, speedup or do carry out other traffic violations. I feel, the basic problem in India is inability and incompetence of police officers who should enforce the laws.

If police can increase the fines to huge amount compared to Indian standards like 5000 Rs for red-light violations or one-way violations and enforce that, Indian roads would be far safer to drive.

Thank you for coping up with Indian traffic.

 
At August 08, 2006 6:23 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Here are some links that I believe will be interested

 
At August 12, 2006 5:44 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Your site is on top of my favourites - Great work I like it.
»

 
At August 15, 2006 8:14 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It seems that the only rule is that there are no rules! The chaos of the road is but a symptom of the depravity of Indian corruption culture where even the buffalo herder can buy a licence from the R.T.O for a few rupees.

On the funnier side, this is from an email that made the rounds a while ago...
http://www.boloji.com/humor/025.htm

"I visited Mumbai recently and agree with the observations about driving. For the benefit of every Tom, Dick and Harry visiting India and daring to drive on Indian roads, I am offering a few hints for survival. They are applicable to every place in India except Bihar, where life outside a vehicle is only marginally safer.

Indian road rules broadly operate within the domain of karma where you do your best and leave the results to your insurance company.

The hints are as follows:

Do we drive on the left or right of the road? The answer is "both". Basically you start on the left of the road, unless it is occupied. In that case, go to the right, unless that is also occupied. Then proceed by occupying the next available gap, as in chess.

Just trust your instincts, ascertain the direction, and proceed. Adherence to road rules leads to much misery and occasional fatality.

Most drivers don't drive, but just aim their vehicles in the intended direction. Don't you get discouraged or underestimate yourself. Except for a belief in reincarnation, the other drivers are not in any better position.

Don't stop at pedestrian crossings just because some fool wants to cross the road. You may do so only if you enjoy being bumped in the back. Pedestrians have been strictly instructed to cross only when traffic is moving slowly or has come to a dead stop because some minister is in town. Still some idiot may try to wade across, but then, let us not talk ill of the dead.

Blowing your horn is not a sign of protest as in some countries. We horn to express joy, resentment, frustration, romance and bare lust (two brisk blasts) or just to mobilize a dozing cow in the middle of the bazaar.

Keep informative books in the glove compartment. You may read them during traffic jams, while awaiting the chief minister's motorcade, or waiting for the rain waters to recede when over-ground traffic meets underground drainage.

Night driving on Indian roads can be an exhilarating experience (for those with the mental makeup of Genghis Khan). In a way, it is like playing Russian roulette, because you do not know who amongst the drivers is loaded. What looks like premature dawn on the horizon turns out to be a truck attempting a speed record. On encountering it, just pull partly into the field adjoining the road until the phenomenon passes. Our roads do not have shoulders, but occasional boulders. Do not blink your lights expecting reciprocation. The only dim thing in the truck is the driver and the peg of illicit arrack he has had at the last stop; his total cerebral functions add up to little more than a naught. Truck drivers are the James Bonds of India and are licensed to kill. Often you may encounter a single powerful beam of light about six feet above the ground. This is not a super motorbike, but a truck approaching you with a single light on, usually the left one. It could be the right one, but never get too close to investigate. You may prove your point posthumously. Of course, all this occurs at night, on the trunk roads.

During the daytime, trucks are more visible, except that the drivers will never show any signal. (And you must watch for the absent signals; they are a greater threat.) Only, you will often observe that the cleaner that sits next to the driver will project his hand and wave hysterically. This is definitely not to be construed as a signal for a left turn. The waving is just an expression of physical relief on a hot day.

Occasionally you might see what looks like an UFO with blinking colored lights and weird sounds emanating from within. This is an illuminated bus, full of happy pilgrims singing bhajans. These pilgrim buses go at breakneck speed, seeking contact with the Almighty, often meeting with success.
Unique to Indian traffic:

Auto Rickshaw (Baby Taxi)

The result of a collision between a rickshaw and an automobile, this three-wheeled vehicle works on an external combustion engine that runs on a mixture of kerosene oil and creosote. This triangular vehicle carries iron rods, gas cylinders or passengers three times its weight and dimension, at an unspecified fare.

After careful geometric calculations, children are folded and packed into these auto rickshaws until some children in the periphery are not in contact with the vehicle at all. Then their school bags are pushed into the microscopic gaps all round so those minor collisions with other vehicles on the road cause no permanent damage. Of course, the peripheral children are charged half the fare and also learn Newton's laws of motion en route to school. Auto-rickshaw drivers follow the road rules depicted in the film Ben Hur and are licensed to irritate.

Mopeds

The moped looks like an oil tin on wheels and makes noise like an electric shaver. It runs 30 miles on a teaspoon of petrol and travels at break-bottom speed. As the sides of the road are too rough for a ride, the moped drivers tend to drive in the middle of the road; they would rather drive under heavier vehicles instead of around them and are often "mopped" off the tarmac.

Leaning Tower of Passes

Most bus passengers are given free passes and during rush hours, there is absolute mayhem (hell). There are passengers hanging off other passengers, who in turn hang off the railings and the overloaded bus leans dangerously, defying laws of gravity but obeying laws of surface tension. As drivers get paid for overload (so many Rupees per kg of passenger), no questions are ever asked. Steer clear of these buses by a width of three passengers.

One-way Street

These boards are put up by traffic people to add jest in their otherwise drab lives. Don't stick to the literal meaning and proceed in one direction. In metaphysical terms, it means that you cannot proceed in two directions at once. So drive as you like, in reverse throughout, if you are the fussy type.

Lest I sound hypercritical, I must add a positive point also.

Rash and fast driving in residential areas has been prevented by providing a "speed breaker"; two for each house. This mound, incidentally, covers the water and drainage pipes for that residence
and is left un-tarred for easy identification by the corporation authorities, should they want to recover the pipe for year-end accounting.

If, after all this, you still want to drive in India, have your lessons between 8 pm and 11 am - when the police have gone home. The citizen is then free to enjoy the 'FREEDOM OF SPEED' enshrined in our constitution.

Having said all this, isn't it true that the accident rate and related deaths are less in India compared to US or other countries ?

– Coen Jukens

 
At May 12, 2008 6:56 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

hi! i struggle in pondicherry from april 1991.basically 2 problems are in pondicherry.1.no compounding fee 2 .no goondas act.we bring students, traffic wardens to help police.but public participation is poor in ponndicherry.pl. visit:
http://roadtraffic.bravehost.com
-pudumai balakrishnan
chief traffic warden
pondicherry

 
At April 20, 2009 11:44 AM, Blogger Hari said...

Chennai traffic cops use high handedness in red light violation. Though I agree I followed a bus blindly, ( I could not see the traffic signal) near Madhya Kailash junction to turn right to Rajiv Gandhi Salai, I was asked to pay a fine of Rs.1000, where I was traveling with my mother & wife at abt 20kms per hr. (Also it was my first offense) They informed that with compounding (red light violation + rash driving + etc..)I was really surprised by this act of wrong collection by the police. I managed to negotiate down to Rs.500 when they informed me that they will not provide a ticket to me. At that point I said I will not pay if you do not give a ticket.
I finally paid for the undeserved ticket @ Rs.500 but now, I am not sure if it even went to the government. We do need to have a website where we can find by entering the ticket number whether the fine has reached the govt. Otherwise those officers who print fake tickets for their gain need to be punished as offenders.
Though deserving police need to be rewarded for their work, currently there is no means of verifying if the fine collected by them was correct or they have misused their powers.
I daily see autos, call taxis, buses jumping signals, but the police do not mind these violations. Any other private party be it a motor cycle or a car is prompted to pay fine. I wish to say that the system needs to be equal for all. Fine all of them.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home