Saturday, September 09, 2006

Open Source Journalism and the One Eyed Baby

I just got back from giving a short talk at blogcamp about the one eyed child born here in Chennai. I am hoping that the blogging community will be able to move this story ahead where I have run into a dead end. Here is what I know and I have a few suggestions on how to move the story forward

The Facts:
The baby girl was born at Kasturba Gandhi Hospital by a woman named Gomathi on or about July 31st 2006. The child had a single eye in the center of her forehead and severe brain damage. She died early last week, but the hospital has not released a cause of death.

An internal hospital report mentioned Cyclopamine, an experimental anti-cancer drug, as a possible cause for the child's condition. A hospital nurse in the ward said that the mother was taking "tablets" to get pregnant because she had been childless for 6 years. The superintendent, Dr. TMT Dhanalakshmi also said that the mother had gone to a fertility clinic, but that the attendant doctors did not take a complete medical history and failed to ask her what drugs the mother had been on, or the name and address of the fertility clinic. It is possible that a drug that the mother was taking helped cause, or bring to term, the baby's condition. While there is no firm evidence that cyclopamine was involved in the child's condition, there are precidents of anti-cancer medications being prescribed as fertility treatments in clinical trials in India as in the case of Letrozole in 2003.

Cyclopamine is a publicly available compound that can be bought from numerous sources in the United States and can be sent to India. One doctor who e-mailed me after the article in Wired News came out said that he had conducted an independent theraputic trial of cyclopamine on a human patient in the United States.

The hospital was not doing its job when it failed to take a medical history, so we need to take up where they left off.

What Next:
To carry this story forward we need to located the fertility clinic in question and determine what drugs the mother was prescribed. We do not want to berate the mother with questions, since she has obviously been through a very traumatic ordeal and do not want to post photos of her all over the internet, but we may need to contact her in order to locate the clinic since the hospital has failed to cooperate. To find her we must locate the child's birth or death certificate and follow the address listed there to the parent's residence. The certificates could be obtained through the RTI act, by connections at the hospital, in the government or any other source for public records.

This is an experiment in Open Source Journalism. I hope that bloggers and activists will be able to crack this case so that we can either say for sure that there was no foul play, and that this was a genetic accident, or hold people accountable for what could be a crime.

Please keep me informed on what you discover, but feel free to blog about your findings and publish in any medium you are comfortale with. Also, members of blog camp have begun to include a tecnoratti tag for "chennaioneeyedbaby" in their posts so we can track this story as it develops.

God speed.

Tags: , ,


Labels:

10 Comments:

At September 09, 2006 8:12 PM, Blogger Sunil Bajpai said...

When we learn about the other drugs, the story should be tagged with their names as well because it could throw up other similar cases.

Also, we need to tag these posts with words like medico-legal, malpractice, names of hospitals and clinics, etc. I'm not suggesting that we create a case against the doctors, drug manufacturers or clinics through psuedo blog-activism. Far from it. What I am suggesting is that the co-operative blogging effort might help us discover the picture that nobody sees today.

If it also encourages the involved health care professionals to co-operate with the investigations, rather than brush aside the enquiries, the bloggers have done their bit.

 
At September 09, 2006 9:49 PM, Blogger anantha said...

Scott: I finally moved my post up from draft. Dunno if I saw it. I am editing it right now. And I spoke to Guru myself before I emailed you his number and he had no idea about anything. So please get in touch with him. Guy is resourceful and am sure we can do something.

 
At September 10, 2006 9:16 AM, Blogger Scott Carney said...

I will contact him soon. Thanks for blogging about this. I am hopeful that we can crack this case.

 
At September 11, 2006 5:15 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have posted my comment below in Anantha's blog too in the hope that the links I have mentioned helps to throw some more light at the practice of clinical drug trials being carried out in India without the patient's consent/knowledge.

"Having watched a TV program here in Australia on Clinical Drug trials being carried out in India, this definitely looks to me like a clinical trial gone horribly wrong. The links below are what I could manage to dig up about this program:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/pro.....924012.stm
http://www.enhancetv.com.au/sh.....d=12668152

And for sure the mother would not have been informed of it. She is bound to be confused at this stage - she has given birth to a deformed baby who has lost her life. Being from India, she’ll resign this incident to fate and carry on with life and the real truth will get buried forever. It is appalling that this piece of news doesn’t get mainstream media coverage while stupid non-issues hit the headlines every single day."

 
At September 11, 2006 5:19 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sorry the links did not come out correctly in the previous post. Here they are:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/this_world/4924012.stm

http://www.enhancetv.com.au/shop/product.php?productid=12668152

Hope, we can help gather momentum in this matter.

 
At September 11, 2006 9:43 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

A friend of mine tests experimental drugs for a living - as in he is the guinea pig! The pay is pretty good but the dynamic is one that debases the human spirit, also what are the long term effects of these drugs? nobody knows.

 
At September 23, 2006 12:02 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hellooooo.. cyclopamine ?

come on.

 
At September 23, 2006 12:10 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ok, I researched, I apologise. They really named this stuff this way.

 
At October 05, 2006 3:43 PM, Blogger Sirensongs: Indologist At Large said...

To carry this story forward we need to located the fertility clinic in question and determine what drugs the mother was prescribed. We do not want to berate the mother with questions, since she has obviously been through a very traumatic ordeal

Even when or if the clinic can be located, it's unlikely they will tell the truth about the actual "tablets" prescribed...you must question the mother to double check (of course, she may not know the actual name of the meds she was given). Sincere good luck!

I am the product of a questionable fertility drug myself (DES, prescribed in the 60s for women prone to miscarriage and later revealed to cause uterine cancer, infertiliity, and possibly, addiction to blogging. ;-) ) My mom had no idea that this was what the doctors were injecting her with...she just trusted them.

 
At November 02, 2006 12:16 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I just want to know, did she get held and loved at all??
please let me know!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home