Thursday, November 27, 2008

India's New Terror Age

Victoria Terminal in Mumbai after a blast last night AFP/Getty

A coordinated series of terrorist attacks in Mumbai today signals a new age of extremism and sectarian violence that will likely increase over time. Since 2001 there have been 24 major terrorist strikes in India resulting in at least 966 deaths. The last five months have been the most harrowing with 302 dead from ten different attacks. As a hostage standoff continues in Colaba that number could rise even higher before the day is out.

What is most troubling about the recent assault on southern Mumbai is the sudden change in tactics. In the last several years most terrorist attacks have come in the form of coordinated small explosive charges, mostly left in nylon bags in commercial districts or IEDs made out of tiffin containers placed on the backs of bicycles in crowded shopping areas. What happened today doesn't fit the pattern of previous events. This wasn't a terrorist attack, this was a coordinated military assault on southern Mumbai executed with precision and calculated to inflict economic, civic, human and symbolic causalities.

Insurgents armed with automatic weapons ran lose on the streets, raided upscale hotels, took hostages and may have specifically targeted foreigners. They set fires in buildings and hijacked police vehicles. Unlike in previous events they weren't afraid to show their faces. These isn't hit and run tactics. This is urban warfare.

Police outside the Taj Hotel in Collaba, Mumbai Prashanth Vishwanathan, NYT

While there is no clear indication of who is behind the most recent string of attacks they must have had significant training and solid financial backing to carry them out. Armed with AK-47's, several boats, satellite phones, grenades and high explosives the group was able to take lower Mumbai completely by surprise and outwit anti-terrorism squads that have been on high alert for months. This level of coordination shows that terrorists here are most likely well networked with other insurgent groups and that they probably share materiel and tactical knowledge. They also have the manpower to embark on large scale operations without putting their entire organization at risk.

While the previous bomb blasts around India could have been carried out by a few dozen dedicated assailants, this attack shows that there must be at least several hundred people planning, training and carrying out logistical missions.

One possible--and even likely--explanation is that whomever is behind this is has been sharing experience and material with any one of the other dozen armed separatist movements across India. The attack today resembles the organizational resilience of other veteran separatist movements in India like the Naxalites, Lakshar e Toiba or even the Sri Lankan LTTE.

This sort of knowledge sharing is not unprecedented. In the past, the LTTE and Naxalites have shared tactical information with groups as far away as the FARC, and while there are vast ideological differences between these groups they are all involved in similar tactical operations and urban warfare. Rediff.com reports that the attackers were in contact with people in Karachi, Pakistan via satelite phone during the operaiton and that the e-mail that claimed responsibility for the attacks had been sent from a source in Russia.

While instances of direct links between terrorist outfits are often difficult to establish concretely, in 2001, three members of the Irish Republican Army (IRA) were arrested in Columbia after sharing bomb making and tactical information with the Farc. These two totally different organizations saw it to be mutually beneficial to share resources, even though there was no ideological connection.

It will be interesting to know what sorts of explosives were used in the attacks last night. Some reports have indicated that they used the explosive RDX, which has both military and industrial applications. A little over a year ago Naxalites stole several tons of explosives from an Essar Steel mine in Chhattisgarh that have been used repeatedly in operations across the country. (At the left is a photo of captured explosives recovered from an unexploded IED that I took while visiting police outposts on the front line of that conflict. Other photos from that story can be found at this link). The haul captured by the Naxals would have been far too much for them to use in their operations against the police and paramilitary forces that the combat in the jungles of central India. There is likely a market for their excess explosives. And what better customer is there than another insurgent group that is trying to destabilize the government?

There is every indication that there will be more attacks to come and that even police successes in capturing terrorists have little impact. When Delhi police raided the house of several suspected terrorists belonging to an outfit called "The Indian Muhajaddin", they found a laptop had illustrated the organization's hierarchical structure. The police conducted dozens of raids across the country and for a while everyone here breathed a little easier.

But the structure of the organization was far from destabilized. Within three months they have been able to mount the most destructive attack in years. The sad fact is that terrorists are gaining ground in India and whomever is behind planning their operations is safe and celebrating the success of their operations.

If anything, this is only the beginning of a new age of terror in India.

Labels: , , , , ,

9 Comments:

At November 27, 2008 11:13 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

holy crap. Glad to hear you're ok
nicole (milan)

 
At November 27, 2008 1:30 PM, Blogger madraskaapi said...

the cowardice act is quite depressing, saddening and terrifying.

life has become such a cheap thing in india.

the government, the politicians, will now step out to condemn the attack, and then will go back to sleep. another attack, another round of condemning will come along. damn!

much much better proactive anti-terroism action is required by the government.

india needs a super-hero !! else, the stupid common man has to wake up as in the movie "a wednesday"....

 
At November 27, 2008 3:19 PM, Blogger Nam said...

The terrorists are Pakistanis.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Cities/Mumbai/Mumbai_attackers_may_be_Pakistani_nationals/articleshow/3764564.cms

 
At November 27, 2008 4:17 PM, Blogger Scott Carney said...

Nam - I think it is too soon to come to conclusions about who exactly is behind the attack, though there are certainly good reasons to think that the attackers could have been trained or funded by sources in Pakistan. The Bombing of India's embassy in Afghanistan immediately comes to mind. Still, we have very little information to go on. The article doesn't even cite sources.

 
At November 27, 2008 6:14 PM, Blogger Nam said...

Scott,

Here is another article from the Indian Express that backs up the Pak link. In my opinion, all of the Mujahideen cells operating in India are sufficiently Islamic, sufficiently anti-Indian and pro-Pak anyway, to be considered Pakistanis. Besides, India does a lousy job of keeping track of its citizens, we have hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants, who quickly register and obtain voting cards, and end up getting involved in terror-related activities.

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/terrorists-came-from-karachi-via-sea-to-mumbai/391329/

Check out this link too. http://islamicterrorism.wordpress.com/2008/09/17/delhi-blasts-full-text-of-indian-mujahideen-email/

 
At November 27, 2008 6:40 PM, Blogger houdini said...

The war of civilisation between the Muslims and the infidels has begun in Indian territory.

2. So said the first statement issued in the name of the so-called Indian Mujahideen (IM) in November, 2007, after the three orchestrated explosions in three towns of Uttar Pradesh outside local courts.

3. We saw the latest round of this war in Mumbai on the night of November 26, 2008, as an unestimated number of terrorists----divided into small groups and wielding hand-held weapons and improvised explosive devices (IEDs)--- literally took control of Mumbai and targeted with frightening precision famous hotels preferred by the rich of the country and foreign tourists, railway stations, a hospital and many other places scattered across this business capital of India.

4. It is not just 9/11. It is not just Madrid, March, 2004. It is not just London, 2006.

5. It is --- I am using the present tense because the situation is still not under control at 5-30 AM despite the Army's assistance being sought--- an act of terrorism, the like of which the world has not seen before. Mind boggles as one tries to think and figure out how the terrorists could have planned and carried out terrorist strikes of such magnitude, territorial spread and ferocity without our intelligence and police having been able to get scent of it. Like what the Vietcong did during the Tet offensive.

http://southasiaanalysis.org/%5Cpapers30%5Cpaper2942.html

 
At November 27, 2008 8:11 PM, Blogger Scott Carney said...

Harcharan, This really isn't a war between civilizations. If this is backed by Muslim extremists--which looks like the case--that is only a small fraction of Muslims in India. At most I would say that this operation has two hundred people behind it.

The thing that is so frightening is how spectacularly well these people have pulled off their operation. The country is paralyzed with everyone looking at this one area of Mumbai. It feels like we are all under attack.

Whomever these people are their ultimate agenda is still not clear. Just like previous attacks in Bangalore, Varnasai, Delhi and Gujarat, the list of demands has been laughable and inarticulate. It almost looks like terror for terror's sake. More likely, I think this is a group trying to spark sectarian violence and have India cannibalize itself like happened after Indira Gandhi was killed.

 
At November 27, 2008 11:42 PM, Blogger wilfredcarney said...

Tim Hobert says "Why can't we all just get along?"

 
At November 30, 2008 12:03 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"The thing that is so frightening is how spectacularly well these people have pulled off their operation. The country is paralyzed with everyone looking at this one area of Mumbai. It feels like we are all under attack"

I enjoy your analysis Scott - but I don't agree with your comment above - I don't find what happened in Mumbai either surprising nor frightening and I definitely don't feel under attack. I keep the media at arm's length...I don't have a television for this precise reason (though I am pretty well informed). Indeed what you say is exactly what the terrorist want you to say - it breeds paranoia - and it gives them the feeling they have won - they have violated our sense of comfort and peace - and indeed they have - but I think one must put it all in perspective. When we fail to think seven generations into the future when it comes to environmental policies - that is frightening...what happened in Mumbai is not frightening - dare I say, it is passe...


No one has the power to intimidate you - unless you give it to them. I am not surprised these attacks happened - not at all. I am not surprised they were so well organized. I am only surprised it took so long to happen.

I was in New York two weeks before September 11th and then in San Francisco when the attacks happened - America was truly a country paralyzed with fear for some months after that. But I think this attack on Mumbai is getting really blown out of proportion. Something like 200 people died. Much less than 9/11. And like you say terrorist attacks are much more common here than in the US.

I remember when I was a child I went to see a lecture about evolution. There are these giant tortoises in the Seychelles and sometimes one of them gets stuck in the mud in the heat of the day and they can die very quickly - basically get cooked alive by the sun. There was a biologist telling this story. He made the point that evolution has its own intelligence. As a compassionate person he could have tried to push the tortoise out of the mud. But perhaps as a scientist it would be better to let nature take its course because though he could rescue the tortoise...the chances are that it would get into the same mess again because of its genetic predisposition.

My point is that these kinds of battles are going to go on for some time. I don't think policies will change much (that being said I would be very interested to see a list of progressive non-partisan things that Muslims and Hindus in India could do as peoples to heal their violent history). It's just a consequence of how power is divided in the modern world - and until we find a more egalitarian approach, a fairer system - there will always be people who want to be violent against the ruling elite - especially when the ruling elite is itself rotten, corrupt and hypocritical. So it's not frightening - it's inevitable. I do not mean to condone what the terrorists do - I do mean to empathize with all sides to try and see the way out of these troubles. I hope I am making myself clear.

There are close to 7 billion people on the planet. One billion are in India. India is one 5th the size of the USA with 3 times as many people. There are horrific differences in wealth here- perhaps more extreme than any other country. The government is often corrupt. It's a democratic country and it is allied with America and the UK. And just as Noam Chomsky says - when there is a dispute between a great power and a scattered dispersed much weaker power...then terrorism and guerilla warfare is the natural consequence.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home