Friday, October 24, 2008

Mobgalore: How Organized Crime Took Over Bangalore

Since the beginning of India's IT boom Bangalore has been the darling of globalization pundits and and development dreamers. The gist, as Thomas Friedman articulates it, is that the world is flattening so that workers and companies can compete for opportunities from anywhere on the planet. Bangalore, of course, is the shiniest example of globalization's success. However, what has been occluded from the discussion is how the massive investments and capital flows into Bangalore have also contributed to the rise of a powerful and violent mafia. Bangalore's economy is growing much faster than its judicial, regulatory and enforcement systems. The gap has proved to be fertile ground for an unregulated, informal and often criminal systems to fill the space.

In this month's issue of WIRED magazine I wrote a story called "The Godfather of Bangalore" where I showed how underworld dons have taken control of many of the city's land dealings by providing an alternate judicial system to mediate land claims. There is no easy way to solve a land dispute in India. Inherited parcels are often contested by dozens of semi-legitimate claimants and court cases routinely take 15 years to come to a judgment. But the pace of land development is relentless, and companies and wealthy individuals don't want to wait for the wheels of justice to finish, they want immediate resolutions.
Muthappa Rai is one of the most feared men in Bangalore

And this is where the land mafia comes in. Rather than go to courts, a land developer can approach one of the five or six major dons in the city and ask them to mediate a dispute, and seal the deal with threats of violence.

In the course of my research I met people who killed with guns, knives and swords. They fought each other and they fought local people for rights to the land. And most of them got rich along the way.

The most famous don (who says that he is now reformed) is Muthappa Rai, who has beaten the rap on several murder and extortion charges, but is commonly referred to as the most powerful underworld figure in the city.

I have been working on this story for three years, following the story of several different underworld figures through newspapers, government reports and on the ground reporting. In July and August I was able to meet the most influential people in the underworld, and the authorities charged with keeping them in check. The picture I've come up with is pretty grim. In effect, very few people have any faith in the law to resolve problems in Bangalore. Mafia dons act with impunity, and routinely defeat legal cases against them.

In my view, Bangalore isn't only an example of the best that India has to offer. Instead Bangalore shows how the worst elements of Indian society can co-exist with a ultra high tech and modern image. Bangalore today isn't much different than it was three hundred years ago when kings ruled the land. The kings of today are power brokers, IT captains of industry, underworld dons and government ministers who play by their own rules. Bangalore isn't neo-colonialist as some people have claimed. It's neo-feudalist.



Check out the video slideshow that I did for WIRED News for more information on the bangalore mafia that didn't make it into the WIRED magazine story. I've also posted more photos that I took during my research here.

Labels: , , , , , ,

16 Comments:

At October 25, 2008 1:28 AM, Blogger mekie said...

Interesting story! I am curious how you managed to obtain the consent of the subjects (assuming you have) to be photographed, especially someone who admits to having murdered people? What have been the repercussions of the story in Bangalore?

 
At October 25, 2008 6:38 AM, Blogger Scott Carney said...

I just asked them for it. They were very willing to talk about their lives.

 
At October 25, 2008 4:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I read the story recently. It is a great article and congrats on writing it.

 
At October 26, 2008 10:09 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You are an excellent journalist. I enjoy reading your stuff. Keep up the good work!

 
At October 27, 2008 7:50 AM, Blogger madraskaapi said...

very interesting article.

 
At November 01, 2008 4:06 PM, Blogger Colin Todhunter said...

Very informative article. I looked at the article on Wired and then read some of the comments. There is a comment from 'sanman' who kind of sticks the knife in. As long as it's good journalism, that's all that matters. And highlighting the huge gap between the officially stated values of any society and what actually takes place in reality is a worthy ideal.

 
At November 02, 2008 10:42 PM, Blogger 100hands said...

Shocking man. Truly shocking. Did you come to Bangalore? You should have given me a shout...
Am coming to Chennai this month to finish the Musalman film, are you around?

 
At November 03, 2008 10:02 PM, Blogger prathibha nandakumar said...

Mr Scott Carney

Well... you did make some attempt at capturing at least one angle of the real situation in Bangalore and i have top give it to you for a sincere attempt. BUt what REALLY has happened after your 'story' hit the online readers is that a lot - i mean A LOT - unhealthy speculations,/use and misuse of your write up is happening here. A weekly tabloid called LANKESH PATRIKE edited by one GOWRI LANKESH of dubious reputation has translated and used it as a lead write up and also made it a centre spread along with all the photos. I doubt if she took your permission. I am not worried aboiut that. But she has also ADDED her own bit to the story cliaming that it is in yours. For example the information abot Mr Agni SREEDHAR. I have checked and cross checked your blog, WIRED and all other online publications and have not found you having written anything about him. I dont knwo from where she has taken it. Your write up is translated by one Parvateesh for Gowri Lankesh. Has he taken permission?
If your answer to my question if you have indeed written about Mr Agni Sreedhar i would like you to give me the link so that i can cross check.
you could reply privately also to my mail at kriyafoundation@hotmail.com if you do not wish to reply here. BUt reply you should i appeal
thank you,
prathibha nandakumar

 
At November 03, 2008 10:52 PM, Blogger prathibha nandakumar said...

sorry, pardon the typos.

 
At November 05, 2008 3:11 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

pratibha,

if scott has not replied to you, well, the portions about agni shridhar is in the video portion of the story. just press play and you will get the info you need. best of luck

 
At November 05, 2008 10:39 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ahem, been reading Aravind Adiga's "White Tiger" lately, have you?

 
At November 06, 2008 10:53 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

anonymous

he did reply and also call to tell that he had NOT given permission to anyone to tranlsate or publish and what madame G did was a definite copywrite infringment and he would contemplate legal action. That apart what is NOT A PART OF THE WIRED write up has been added by selecting from the 'notes'. plse read this week's Agni for all details.

 
At November 07, 2008 8:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mr Corney

Without meaning any offence to your sincere efforts would like to tell you that Land Mafia in Bangalore is the story every cub-crime reporter in Bangalore cuts his teeth. There is nothing new in what you have written and all this has been written hundred times over.

 
At November 07, 2008 9:19 AM, Blogger Scott Carney said...

I'd love to meet those cub reporters.

 
At November 15, 2008 10:13 AM, Blogger In love with the city said...

I absolutely loved the story, I look forward to reading more of your work.

 
At November 16, 2008 1:43 AM, Blogger Marianas Pride said...

I found your blog this morning. AWESOME! Every time I think things are bad here in my small island of Saipan, I read your blog and realize just how good we have it...thanks! ;)

 

Post a Comment

<< Home